I’m sure now that Mary Jane McLean (and probably her mother nee Eliza Boak) lived at Woodford House in 1869 with Janey’s elder half-sister Margaret Shiels and her husband John Shiels. I don’t think they owned it but managed the house for the owner. This is also where William Mark Forster married Mary Jane in 1869. You need to imagine the shingle roof though apparently the building hasn’t changed much otherwise.
Woodford House (now Woodford Academy) Built in the 1830s in the Blue Mountains of new South Wales, managed by John and Margaret Shiels in 1869 and where William Mark Forster married Mary Jane McLean the same year
Here’s my reasoning: Towards the end of the inquest report into the fire at Shiels’ house at Regentville near Penrith we read “Thomas Ellison, sworn: I am a licenced publican of Seventeen-mile Hollow, Bathurst Road. I know John Shiels; he lives at Bass’s (Woodford), about three miles from me”. I could find nothing about a Bass’s, but lots about Buss’s at Twenty-mile Hollow on the Bathurst Road. Here’s a quote about the history of Woodford House
“In 1855 Hogan sold the property to William Buss of Cowra, who was an ex-convict transported for life on the ‘Phoenix’ in 1828 for horse stealing. Buss was granted a ticket of leave in 1836, and a conditional pardon in 1843. The inn became known as “The King’s Arms”. Buss was a colourful and popular publican, and the inn was also known as “Buss’s Inn”. The Gold Rush brought an increase in traffic travelling west to the Turon and Bathurst gold fields. The King’s Arms was one of a series of wayside inns providing accomodation and refreshments far travellers. Buss retained the property until his death in 1867. He bequeathed all his properly to his wife Bridget. In August 1868 Bridget Buss sold the property to Alfred Fairfax. Fairfax renamed the building “Woodford House” and lived there intermittently. The main use during the late 1800’s was as a mountain retreat or fashionable boarding house.”
Between January 1869 and 23 Oct 1869 the following advertisement repeatedly appeared in The Sydney Morning Herald:
Advertisement for Woodford (late Buss’s), Blue Mountains by J. Sheils: from Sydney Morning Herald 6 Oct 1869
There was little else at Woodford in the 1860s in any case. Even the new railway station wasn’t called “Woodford” until 1871.
A footnote to this is the disappearance after Oct 1869 of not only Eliza McLean but also John Sheils. His wife Margaret is evidently managing properties in Bathurst without him by 1873. Does anybody know where he went?
CHANGE of AIR, BATHURST – Mrs. Sheils (late of Regentville and Woodford) has opened a place for the above…Smith’s Cottage, Russell St., Bathurst. from Sydney Morning Herald 24 May 1873
What do you think? I was going to post about James McLean, but this is already too long.
Thanks so much to a couple of you who got back with comments regarding my previous post. It encourages me to peg on!
taggerty 
Great to see what you found out about Eliza McLean (nee Bolk, Boak, whatever). You may not have solved the mystery, but have certainly moved a lot closer. My theory that she may have married Matthew Nesbitt, in 1859, now looks like a dead duck.
With regard to James McLean, son of Edward McLean & Mary Jane Gordon, the following may be of interest:
Believed to have died Bathurst NSW 1916 surname recorded as Maclean. NSW 1916/3995.
Mr. James MacLean, a native of the North of Ireland, who came to Australia when he was two years of age, and subsequently took up his residence in Bathurst, and lived here for 40 years, died at his residence, Lambert-street, yesterday afternoon. The deceased, who followed the occupation of a saddler, was harness-maker for Cobb and Co. in the old coaching days, and he was subsequently employed by the Pullbrook firm. At the time of his death, Mr. MacLean had just returned from a two years’ trip to the old country. He leaves a family of two sons and two daughters. The sons are Mr. James MacLean, manager of the Galong Freezing Works, near Harden; Mr. Hector MacLean, a dairyman, of Bathurst. The daughters are Mrs M. Ryan and Miss Sarah McLean.
(National Advocate, Bathurst, 4/1/1916)
The death registration only has his father’s name, Edward, recorded. No name for his mother. However, his age on arrival aligns with what is known of the family, assuming the newspaper article is correct. The only way to be sure would be to obtain the death certificate.
Trust this is of assistance.
On another tangent, if it is the death of James McLean, it will be the second distant relation that I have who was involved with Cob & Co. One of my great great uncles, on my father’s side, was instrumental in developing Cobb & Co routes in NSW, around Forbes, and later was a part owner of Cobb & Co in Queensland. He assisted in taking a large number of coaches from Bendigo to Forbes & Bathurst in 1862. I wonder if he ever met James McLean?
Regards,
Geoff Brown
LikeLike
Thanks Geoff! I think you’re on the money about James McLean. I’ve spent all morning on him and am about to post about him! I should admit it was Bruce who originally found the article about the fire 🙂
LikeLike
HI Just wondering if you have any more details about John Shiels e.g his date of birth perhaps?
LikeLike
Hi Alison,
All the info I have is in chapter 5: https://taggerty.net/the-story/chap-5-the-mcleans-from-the-north-of-ireland-via-the-sarah-botsford-to-sydney-and-the-blue-mountains/ or else in the family tree attached to my blog
LikeLike